Greatest Mistakes with Healthy Weight Gain Plans

Greatest Mistakes with Healthy Weight Gain Plans

Healthy weight gain is something many athletes strive towards, yet very few accomplish the task with ease. Contrary to popular belief, there is a strategy behind gaining weight the correct way. The first thing to know is that It is not in your best interest to eat whatever you want whenever you want!

In fact, you may have a coach or parent reinforcing this approach at the moment.  Although I realize this method might make the most sense, it is not the approach which will provide the best results.

(And if deep down, you secretly have no interest in reading this article and you would just like to be told what to eat and when, you can skip to our Ultimate Weight Gain Guide.)

So, I want you to ask yourself:
How can I gain weight the safest and fastest way possible? How do I make sure I don’t add pounds and pounds of body fat? How do I do this with avoiding junk so I don’t feel sick or end up with GI distress to the point that I go to the bathroom in my pants!?

I definitely understand your confusion and questions. To help answer your concerns and provide real-life guidance, I pulled three food journals from my athletes this week for you to view. In this article, we will use food journals as a more detailed way to address common dietary patterns of athletes trying to gain weight. We will also discuss the most common pitfalls and greatest mistakes when it comes to healthy weight gain.

First things first….

What Does “Healthy Weight Gain Mean?”

Most often, healthy weight gain is the strategic approach an athlete takes to gain weight, predominately muscle mass, to have the best opportunity to excel in his or her sport.

This does not necessarily mean “bulking up”. 

In certain situations, the athlete may be looking to gain weight for health-related reasons. For example, specific biological processes in the human body stop when calorie and overall nutrient intake is not meeting estimated needs- think of the young female athlete who suddenly stops menstruating or the athlete who has a wound that does not heal for months.

These are classic signs of inadequate nutrition.

This Brings Us To a Couple of Key Concepts:

  1. When trying to gain weight more healthily, you should place greater emphasis on appropriate meal timing.
  2. Be sure to place extra care in trying to achieve all macro and micronutrient needs.
In other words, an athlete trying to gain weight more healthfully is not just counting calories. We should be focusing on rotating foods in the diet to boost the immune system by providing variety.  This includes balancing protein, carbohydrates, and fat at each meal vs. just heaping piles of random fast-food on the plate. This also includes the implementation of daily recovery nutrition immediately after a tough workout.

OK, onto the next issue we commonly encounter:

Quantity without quality is a major mistake. 

The athlete attempting to consciously gain weight tries quite desperately to focus on quality of food instead of solely quantity. When weight increases as a result of an athlete consuming fresh whole foods, the athlete often experiences greater energy and strength in the process. On the other hand, the “old school” weight gain athlete who is eating whatever he or she wants in order to pack on the pounds may experience weight gains well as fatigue, digestive issues, and interrupted sleep patterns.Not to mention, a little more body fat than expected.

Now that we’ve covered the basics, let’s take a look at a few real-life food journals. Below you will see the journals of 3 different athletes with goals of gaining weight, and the feedback I provided highlighted in green. Excuse the formatting differences since other than the names being changed for privacy, these were the actual journals submitted to me.

Marco’s Food Journal

Day 1

7:15 – 3 scrambled eggs 2 pieces of peanut butter toast  Consider adding a few veggies to the eggs. More color = better recovery and cell repair!
10:00 – KIND granola bar and an apple  Good
1:00 – chicken breast and baked potato, protein shake  Great, however, I would make sure to add salsa, guacamole, or olive oil and spices to the baked potato for a few extra calories. Every ounce counts and you do not want to miss an ample opportunity for additional fuel.
4:00 – Salad with bacon bits, shredded mozzarella, and croutons  Add a quality dressing that is calorically dense. Examples might include fresh lemon juice and olive oil, avocado-based dressing, sesame oil with fresh ginger.
7:15 – 3 chicken tacos with tomatoes peppers and shredded cheese  Consider adding a side of beans and brown rice.
9:00 – protein shake w/ 10 oz of milk 4 scoops of protein powder, frozen banana, 2 tablespoons of peanut butter  This shake is excellent for weight gain. The key here is to make sure that

DAY 2

9:00 – 3 scrambled eggs 2 pieces of toast with chocolate milk Add a few fresh veggies and 1-2 ounces of organic meat to the scrambled eggs. The breakfast is OK as is, but knowing that this athlete is trying to gain lean mass, we want to add as much color and lean protein to meals when appropriate.
12:00 – turkey sandwich with guacamole  Awesome- guacamole is one of the most calorically dense, yet nutrient rich spreads for a sandwich. #2 in line would be hummus.
3:00 – banana and peanut butter Snack of champions
6:00 – steak filet, corn and rice, roll and salad  Although I am not sure of the exact portions on Sam’s plate, this is a balanced meal.
8:45 – protein shake 10 oz of milk 4 scoops of protein powder, frozen banana, 2 tablespoons of peanut butter  Excellent
9:30 – almonds  Great!

DAY 3

7:15 – 2 scrambled eggs 2 pieces of toast  Add a few spoonfuls of guacamole on top of the eggs.
10:05 – Apple and peanut butter  Excellent!
1:10 – chicken breast, salad, and baked potato Add a tablespoon of grass-fed butter if a red skin potato or teaspoons of coconut oil and cinnamon to a sweet potato.
4:00 – turkey sandwich with lettuce and mustard  Add a side of hummus veggie sticks and pita chips
6:00 – pasta and salad with roll Add 1-2 TBSP olive oil to salad
8:00 – almonds and protein shake  Add a banana to the shake.

Marco’s food journal is better than most that I see. His meal timing is impeccable and it appears that he is trying his best to choose quality foods.

As you will see my edits in green, the core of Marco’s meals are appropriate, but he would benefit from rounding out some of his meals, mainly in the way of good quality fat. Adding a few 50-100 calories here and there throughout the day may not seem like it is serving much purpose. However, when this is done each day over several weeks, an athlete will find that he or she is gradually able to gain weight without ever feeling lethargic or overstuffed.

If you are like Marco in the sense that you are eating well, eating often, and feel that you can’t possibly add any more food to your repertoire, focus on keeping the food volume low, but calories high. This means adding 1 teaspoon to 2 TBSP of plant-based fat to meals and snacks. For example, adding a TBSP of olive oil to your salad as part of the dressing or adding a couple teaspoons of guacamole as a sandwich spread.

While this approach may provide somewhat fast results, the end result is weight gain, yes, but a higher percentage of body fat is gained vs. lean muscle. Worst of all? Over time, this approach often leads to an increase in blood sugar, cholesterol, and inflammation in the body.

I realize that as a young athlete, some of you care so much about making weight that you just want to make it happen in the fastest way possible. However, I promise that you will be sorry one day when your health starts to decline and you are diagnosed with conditions and diseases that you never thought would appear in your medical chart!

What you put on the end of your fork can extend your life and improve your health just as fast as it can deteriorate your health. You decide.

Now let’s take a look at Nate’s food journal. Nate’s approach is what I lovingly refer to as the “old school” approach to weight gain. In other words, eat whatever you want, whenever you want, especially if it tastes good. This style of weight gain focuses more on convenience and taste preference and does not take into consideration any aspect of health.

Nate’s Food Journal

DAY 1

7:00 – 3 eggs with 1 piece of American cheese, 2 pieces of toast  Choose grass-fed cheddar cheese instead of American and add veggies. For a less manufactured, more calorically / nutrient dense version of bread, check out this link for cashew bread and enjoy two pieces in place of traditional toast.
12:20 – 1 Peanut butter and jelly sandwich, 2 bags of chips, 1 Fruit cup, and 1 Bag of cheese crackers
Keep the sandwich, swap the chips for whole grain crackers and 2 TBSP of hummus. Remove processed, chemical-laden cheese crackers and replace with homemade trail mix containing mixed nuts, pumpkin seeds, shredded coconut flakes, dried cranberries, and bananas.
7:00 – 10 boneless wings, 1 side of fries, 5 Mozzarella sticks, 1/2 of a soft pretzel, 7 Onion rings  While the calories in this meal are exceptionally high (likely exceeding 1000kcal), the tough part is that this meal contains approximately 3 days worth of saturated fat intake!! Fat is important for human health, but fat in the saturated form (fried foods) is the type of fat that can be detrimental to our overall health and performance. Not to mention, extremely inflammatory. If this athlete tends to be extremely hungry late at night, the best option would have been to consume a balanced dinner around 5:30 pm and then having a weight gain shake around 7:00 – Check out our article from a few months ago for recipes on homemade weight gain shakes.

DAY 2

9:30 A.M – 2 Granola bars  Consider spreading a TBSP of sunflower seed butter on the first granola bar and place the second granola bar on top, sandwich style. This allows for a more balanced snack as well as an additional 90 calories without dramatically changing volume.
12:10 P.M – 1 Peanut butter and jelly Sandwich, 1 Popcorn Chicken Bowl, 1 Bag of chips, 1 fruit cup, 1 cup of applesauce
3:00 P.M –  2 pieces of pizza
7:00 P.M – 1 plate of homemade chicken and pasta casserole, 1 cup of applesauce 9:30 P.M – 1 plate of homemade chicken and pasta casserole Adding a side of cooked veggies to the casserole meal would be a great way to add a few extra calories while improving overall health. Remember, the more color you eat, the better your cells can repair each day. This athlete could also consider adding 1-2 TBSP of collagen gelatin to his applesauce. Collagen Gelatin is a great way to reach your daily protein goal while also helping to rebuild the lining of your gut and strengthen the soft tissue in your body. This is particularly helpful for the athletes playing contact sports.

DAY 3

10:30 A.M – 4 eggs with 1 piece of American cheese, 2 pieces of toast
2:30P.M- 1 Burrito with rice, chicken, steak, cheese, and lettuce, 1 Bag of tortilla chips  The plus side of these meals is that they contain an adequate amount of protein, carbohydrate and fat. The downside is that American Cheese, toast, burrito shells and tortilla chips are highly processed, therefore causing inflammation in the body. The better option would have been a side of eggs with a few TBSP of grass-fed cheddar cheese and a burrito bowl with quinoa, veggies, grilled chicken, salsa, corn, and guacamole.
6:00 P.M – 2 Cheeseburgers, 2 eggs, 1 hotdog Dinner is a bit off balance. Protein goals are being blown out of the water and this meal contains ZERO balanced, non-processed carbohydrate and ZERO anti-inflammatory fat. A better options would have been a 3 egg veggie omelet with an ounce or two of lean meat, roasted potatoes, and a side salad with a few TBSP of olive oil.
7:00 P.M – 1 Bag of Teddy Grahams
9:00 P.M – 1 Bag of chips Processed snacks such as graham crackers that contain added sugar and or consist primarily of carbohydrates (chips) are not the greatest choice before bed. It would have been better for this athlete to choose a bedtime snack that contained lean protein before bed. A snack rich in lean protein would better stabilize blood sugar and promote muscle protein synthesis while asleep
Now let’s take a look at our final athlete, Jay. Jay is in a slightly more complicated situation because he is trying to lose body fat while putting on muscle. Although this may sound counter-intuitive, it is certainly possible.

If this sounds like you, keep in mind that it is imperative that you meet your daily calorie goals. However, the key here is to make sure your protein and carbohydrate needs are calculated appropriately and that these goals are met as well.  Not sure how to calculate your calorie goal? Check out this link.

Ready to calculate your exact protein and carbohydrate goals? Check out our posts on recommended protein intake and recommended carbohydrate intake. 

Jay’s Food Journal

DAY 1

Peanut butter and jelly sandwich
Apple
Lucky charms
While I can certainly appreciate the fact that Josh is trying to keep his calories in check, he is nowhere near where he needs to be for daily calorie intake!! In this situation, he should be focused on eating 3 balanced meals and a recovery shake at the very least. Why? It is the most efficient way to reach his daily calorie and protein goals while still keeping blood sugar in check and metabolism humming.

DAY 2

Peanut butter and jelly sandwich
Apple
Apple & Nutrigrain bar
Cheerios
Looks like we have the exact same situation again. Sometimes this occurs because an athlete truly believes they are eating what they need. Sound familiar? To avoid this pitfall, calculate your nutrient needs from the links listed above. Next, work with a local dietitian to figure out how this translates to meals and snacks each day. There is a good chance you will find that you were nowhere near your goal!

DAY 3

Peanut butter and jelly sandwich
Half a ham sandwich
Half a turkey sandwich
2 apples
Other times a macronutrient deficiency or inadequate calorie intake occurs because an athlete never feels hungry or becomes full too quickly. If this sounds like you, it’s time to ask yourself,”Am I having at least one large bowel movement each day? Do I have pain or bloating after I eat?” If this is the case, you may have trouble with digestion and that calls for a visit with your doctor or dietitian.
If you answered no to these questions, consider the following tips and tricks:
  1. Do not drink fluid with meals, instead, choose to drink fluid between meals. This will help to prevent early satiety.
  2. Choose to eat fruits and veggies after your main course, not before! This helps to ensure that you are consuming a greater amount of calories before becoming full.
  3. Focus on eating smaller meals/snacks/shakes every 2-3 hours vs. a very large meal 2-3x/day.
  4. Avoid liquid-based foods such as soup as these foods can cause you to feel full despite the meal being very low on the calorie spectrum.
In summary, there is a right way and a less ideal way to achieve healthy weight gain. As long as you are focusing on appropriate meal timing, choosing whole foods, and keep added sugar to a minimum all while meeting the daily macronutrient goals that you set for yourself, you will reach your goal weight easier and faster than you ever imagined!
If you are looking for more extensive guidance regarding weight gain, check out our Ultimate Weight Gain Guide. Everything you need to succeed is in this guide – shake and meal recipes, tips and tricks for success, supplement suggestions, a grocery guide and a meal plan with snacks!
If you’re looking for an awesome handout to help you or your team stay focused and healthy weight gain, check out our handout Gain Weight Like a Champion.
Do you have any tips or tricks for healthy weight gain? Have you experienced success in gaining weight by taking a more healthful approach? Please share your thoughts below!

About The Author

Kylene Bogden

Kylene Bogden is one of the most well respected Functional Sports Dietitians in the United States. As a high school and collegiate sprinter, she experienced recurrent injury and fatigue. After years of constant struggle, she eventually learned that an abundance of processed foods and poor fueling strategies were the root of her performance issues. Kylene's personal journey as an athlete fueled her passion for finding a more progressive approach to sports nutrition. Since then, she has helped thousands of individuals dramatically improve overall health and athletic performance by taking a whole food approach. To learn more about Kylene's story and how a functional nutrition approach can help you to achieve your goals, simply click on the contact us link in the upper right-hand corner today!

Trackbacks/Pingbacks

  1. 3 Powerful and Pure Weight Gain Shakes – FWDfuel - […] []).push({}); The struggle can be very real for the health conscious athlete who is trying to gain weight in…

Leave a reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

Join Us!

America’s Functional Sports Nutrition Expert

Kylene Bogden Sports Nutrition Dietitian

Kylene Bogden Sports Nutrition Dietitian

Kylene Bogden, RDN

Board Certified Sports Dietitian

Certified LEAP Therapist

Consultant to collegiate and professional teams

Official dietitian of athletes everywhere who are looking for a cutting edge approach to improving their performance.

Ultimate Elimination Diet Guide

Elimination Diet Meal Plan

Thrive Market

Professional Grade Supplements

Wellevate

BEST Ways to Detox

Table of foods good for detoxifying with such as blueberries, salmon, broccoli, and brussels sprouts

Vitamix S50 Space Saving Blender

Performance Snack and Food List

Thrive Market

Epic Almond & Cranberry Turkey Bars 12 bars

Farm to table meats

Subscribe To Our Newsletter

Join our mailing list now to receive the latest news and updates from our team AND a FREE copy of our 3 Day Whole Food Meal Plan ($195 value) to increase energy, improve gut function, and performance!

You have Successfully Subscribed!

Food Allergy Stomach Pain Relief

Ready to fix a leaky gut?

Subscribe now for your free copy of our 4 Top Secrets to Heal Leaky Gut Syndrome Fast.

You have Successfully Subscribed!

Pin It on Pinterest

Share This

Share this post with your friends!